Gravity simulator
A star torn by a small black hole
A star like the Sun on a parabola past a black hole of 20 Suns, the kind a massive star leaves when it dies. Its tidal radius is only 2.7 times its own radius, and it passes just outside its surface: deep enough for the tide to take about four fifths of it.
A small hole and a big star
A tide tears a star apart at its tidal radius, R(M/m)^⅓, which grows only as the cube root of the hole’s mass, while the hole’s own size grows with its mass. So the smaller the hole, the further outside it a star comes apart, and a star is a far larger share of the scene: here the hole moves almost a twentieth as far as the star does, round their centre of mass. Dense star clusters, where stars and holes crowd together, should see such meetings now and then (Kremer and others, 2019).
A star like the Sun, with a dense core, holds its centre tight, so a pass takes only (ℛt/r_p)³ of it, with ℛt less than half the tidal radius for a hole this small (Ryu and others, 2020). What is left is bound to the hole by the tide it raised, and comes back.
Fed far past its limit
The stripped gas falls back within hours, around a billion times faster than the hole could take it while its own light held off what falls. Fed like that, a disk is slim: it carries most of its heat into the hole and puffs up. Its temperature falls only as r^−½, one over the square root of the distance, so it stays white-hot far out. Most of it cannot get in and leaves again in a wind, which hides the hole and its disk.
Hidden in its own wind
What the hole cannot take is blown off at the escape speed from where it arrives, here about 3,000 km/s. The wind is ionised, its free electrons scatter light, and nothing inside it can be seen. Within hours of the gas coming back, a photosphere at 50,000 K grows out from the hole and swallows the disk. It goes on growing until its gas is cool enough, about 10,000 K, for hydrogen to recombine and let light through, several AU out (Shakura and Sunyaev 1973; Strubbe and Quataert 2009).
It does not swell and shrink with each change in what the hole is fed. The gas already blown keeps the light it left with and carries it out at its own speed, so the photosphere grows steadily as the newest, thickest gas goes out, here to over 5 AU in four days, and once the feeding has passed its peak it shrinks back only slowly, as that gas thins.
What’s on screen
The ideas behind what the scene shows, each with what the simulator does and leaves out, and where to read more.
Stars torn apart by black holes
A star that strays too close to a black hole is pulled apart by the difference in its pull.
Gravity weakens with distance, so a black hole pulls harder on the near side of a star than on its far side. Far away that stretch is tiny beside the star’s own gravity, but it grows as the cube of how close the star comes, and inside the tidal radius it wins. That radius is R⋆(M•/M⋆)^⅓: the star’s radius R⋆ times the cube root of how many times heavier the hole, M•, is than the star, M⋆. For the Sun at the four-million-Sun hole in the middle of the Milky Way that is about 0.7 AU.
A star that passes well inside is torn apart; one that only grazes the radius loses its outer layers and goes on, smaller, in a partial disruption. How much it loses depends on how its mass is spread: a star like the Sun, with a dense core, holds on far closer than a red dwarf of uniform density. Of the gas torn off, about half is bound to the hole and half is flung away, because the tide spreads it over a range of orbital energies.
The bound half falls back over weeks to years, at a rate that falls off as t^−5/3, time to the power −5/3, and as it settles round the hole it lights a flare that can outshine the galaxy for months: a tidal disruption event. Around a hundred have been seen, at a rate of about one per galaxy every ten to a hundred thousand years. A hole heavier than about a hundred million Suns has its horizon outside the tidal radius of a star like the Sun, and swallows it whole.
In the simulator. Each pass takes the share of the star that simulations give for its kind and for how close it comes. The gas leaves the star’s near and far tips on Kepler orbits of its own, is turned by Einstein’s law as it passes the hole, and comes back spread smoothly in time, as t^−5/3. The hole takes in only what reaches it, and no faster than its Eddington limit. Until the gas is swallowed or blown away it goes on pulling, so nothing nearby feels the star vanish. The simulator counts all of it as if it sat at the hole, and gas flung away stops pulling on the nearest other body once it has passed it. Where a second hole or a heavy star would bend the gas’s path during its flight, the simulator instead follows that gas in the pull of every heavy body as they move. It does so until the gas falls back on to one hole, whose disk it then lights and feeds, or leaves them all. This gas does not collide with itself or push back except where it shocks at a hole, and it pulls from the place of whichever body pulls hardest on it. Gas round a hole that merges into another goes on round the merged hole. The star is drawn far larger than a real one would be, so its stream is wider and comes back sooner.
Read more
- Wikipedia, Tidal disruption event, an introduction.
- S. Gezari (2021), Tidal Disruption Events, Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics: a review of what has been seen.
- M. J. Rees (1988), Tidal disruption of stars by black holes of 10⁶–10⁸ solar masses in nearby galaxies, Nature: half the gas bound, and the flare.
- E. S. Phinney (1989), Manifestations of a Massive Black Hole in the Galactic Center, IAU Symposium 136: the returning gas, falling off as time to the power −5/3.
- T. Ryu and others (2020), Tidal Disruptions of Main-sequence Stars. I. Observable Quantities and Their Dependence on Stellar and Black Hole Mass, The Astrophysical Journal: how much a pass takes.
Also in Star torn apart, Star slowly eaten, Gas giant torn apart.
Wind photospheres
A black hole fed far faster than it can swallow blows the rest away, and hides behind the glowing surface of its own wind.
When gas reaches a black hole faster than its Eddington limit allows (see The Eddington limit), the light of the infalling gas is strong enough to push much of it back out. What cannot get in leaves as a thick, fast wind, at about the escape speed from where it starts: thousands of kilometres a second, up to a sizeable fraction of the speed of light.
The wind is hot enough to be ionised, and free electrons scatter light very readily. So the wind is opaque, and what we see is its photosphere: the surface from which light last scatters before it gets away, as the Sun’s visible surface is. In a wind it lies where the gas further out is just thick enough to scatter light about once on its way out (one optical depth), and it can be far larger than the disk inside it: from a few to hundreds of AU. Its temperature, tens of thousands of kelvin, is set by its light spread over its area. That is why the optical flares of stars torn by black holes look like glowing balls at 20,000 to 40,000 K with radii of 10¹⁴ to 10¹⁵ cm, about 7 to 70 AU, far larger and cooler than any disk.
A photosphere cannot grow without end. Further out the gas cools, and below about 10,000 K hydrogen recombines and the gas turns clear, as it does in the photosphere of a type IIP supernova. Nor is a wind round: the light escapes most easily along the disk’s axis, which opens a funnel about each end of it, narrower the harder the hole is fed, so looking down the axis you see deeper, hotter gas.
In the simulator. Each stretch of the wind keeps how hard it was blown, how fast and the light it carried, and goes out at its own speed, so the photosphere grows and shrinks only as the gas does, not with every change in the stream. Its face darkens towards its edge, as a scattering atmosphere’s does, and is hotter wherever the eye sees deeper into it. Wind photospheres, under Colours in View, turns it off to show the disk a real wind would hide.
Read more
- Wikipedia, Photosphere, and Optical depth, for the idea.
- L. E. Strubbe and E. Quataert (2009), Optical flares from the tidal disruption of stars by massive black holes, Monthly Notices of the RAS: the wind and its photosphere.
- L. Dai and others (2018), A Unified Model for Tidal Disruption Events, The Astrophysical Journal Letters: the funnel, and why the angle we see from matters.
- S. van Velzen and others (2020), Optical-Ultraviolet Tidal Disruption Events, Space Science Reviews: the temperatures and radii seen.
- A. R. King (2009), Masses, beaming and Eddington ratios in ultraluminous X-ray sources, Monthly Notices of the RAS: how wide the funnels open.
Also in Star slowly eaten, Star torn apart.
The Eddington limit
How brightly anything can shine before its own light pushes away the gas that feeds it.
Light carries momentum. As it streams out through ionised gas, every electron it scatters is pushed outwards, and the electrons drag the protons with them. At a luminosity of 4πGMm_pc/σ_T, about 33,000 Suns for every Sun’s mass, the push balances gravity: Arthur Eddington’s limit. Here m_p is the proton’s mass and σ_T the electron’s size as a target for light, its Thomson cross-section. A black hole cannot shine much above it while it swallows, and the rate of feeding that would give that light, about a fiftieth of a millionth of its own mass a year, is its Eddington rate: a hundredth of a Sun a year for a hole of half a million Suns.
Feeding faster is possible. Gas can still fall in, carrying its light with it before that light can escape, and what cannot get in is blown off as a wind. The light then grows only slowly with the feeding, about as L_Edd(1 + ln ṁ), where L_Edd is the limit and ṁ is how many times its Eddington rate the hole is fed. Holes newly feeding on a torn star, and perhaps some ultraluminous X-ray sources in nearby galaxies, are fed many times their limit.
In the simulator. A hole fed ṁ times its rate swallows no more than its limit, less what leaves as light, so it gains mass only slowly, and the rest becomes its wind. Inside a star it is different: the gas is so dense that its light is trapped and carried in, so a hole that sinks to a star’s core keeps a quarter of the star, a choice within what simulations allow, and what it takes throws the rest out as an explosion of about 10⁵¹ erg for 2.5 Suns taken, drawn as a hydrogen-rich supernova. The hole of 20 Suns in Star torn by a small hole is fed about a hundred million times its limit at the peak.
Read more
- Wikipedia, Eddington luminosity, an introduction.
- N. I. Shakura and R. A. Sunyaev (1973), Black holes in binary systems. Observational appearance, Astronomy and Astrophysics: disks, and what happens past the limit.
- M. A. Abramowicz and others (1988), Slim accretion disks, The Astrophysical Journal: gas that carries its light in.
Also in Star slowly eaten, Star torn apart, Quasar.
Places to visit
Zoom out of any scene to reach the galaxy it lives in and the cosmic web beyond it, or go straight there.
- The cosmic web Filaments of galaxies hundreds of millions of light-years long, clusters and voids.
- The Milky Way Our galaxy, with the Sun and its neighbours in their real places.
- Andromeda The nearest large galaxy, where it is seen from the Sun, with M32 and M110.
- The Large Magellanic Cloud The Milky Way’s largest satellite, with the Small Cloud and the Magellanic Stream.
- M87 and the Virgo cluster The giant elliptical with its jet, at its real distance and direction in the web.
- The Antennae Two spiral galaxies in collision.
- The Mice A pair of galaxies drawing out long tidal tails.
- The Whirlpool A grand-design spiral with its companion at the end of an arm.
- The Cartwheel A head-on collision leaving an expanding ring of new stars.
- Arp 273 A spiral whose arms a companion’s plunge threw into a rose.
- The Tadpole A spiral with a single tail of stars 100 kpc long.
- Stephan’s Quintet A compact group: one galaxy crashing through three others, a fifth waiting to fall in.
Things to try
- Follow Torn star in Bodies and watch it stretch as it nears the hole. Its tips, where the tide takes most of its gravity, run cooler and redder.
- Move the star’s closest approach out: at twice as far a pass takes about a tenth of it, and beyond five and a half times as far the tide only stretches it.
- Zoom out once its gas is back: the hole is a blue-white ball of hot gas growing by about 1.6 AU a day.
- Raise the hole to a few thousand Suns: the tide reaches out less far beside the hole’s size, and the disk runs cooler.
More scenarios
- A star torn apart by a black hole A Sun-like star dives at a black hole and the tide tears it into a stream of gas: half is flung away, half returns to light a fading disk.
- A star slowly eaten by a black hole A star bound to a black hole loses gas at every close pass. The gas gathers into a disk while the star shrinks, until the tide can finish it.
- A star through a black hole’s disk A star on a tilted orbit punches through the disk of a black hole of 100 million Suns twice an orbit: one proposed cause of repeating X-ray flares.
