OpenWorldLab

Loading interactive view…

Gravity simulator

A Jupiter torn apart by a black hole

A Jupiter on a long orbit round a black hole of 4.1 million Suns, as heavy as Sagittarius A*, from 3.6 AU in to about 1.1 AU. A gas giant has nothing to crack, so it is torn the way a star is: drawn out on the way in, then poured off both ends into a stream of its own gas that winds round the hole into a disk. What is left is its core.

Nothing to crack

Nothing holds a gas giant together but its own gravity, so it flows as the tide stretches it. Roche’s limit for such a body on a circular orbit is about 2.44 times the radius of what it orbits, scaled by the cube root of their densities: about 1.9 AU for Jupiter at this hole, more than twice as far out as an Earth is torn. Jupiter is the less dense of the two, so its own gravity holds it more weakly.

On a single pass a giant is torn as a star is. The share a pass takes is (ℛt/r_p)³, where ℛt is how close a pass must come to take all of it, found from simulations of stars (Ryu and others, 2020) with Jupiter taken as a ball of gas about three times denser at its centre than on average. For Jupiter at this hole, under Einstein’s law, ℛt is about 1.4 AU, so this pass takes all of it.

Poured out, and its core left

Jupiter is drawn out from where a pass would take a twentieth of it, more than twice its closest distance, and stretches as it falls. Its gas leaves after the closest point, as simulations of torn stars find, from both ends at once in one stream, and moves on as the part of the planet it left did: the near end deeper in the hole’s well, the far end higher out. The fall from 3.6 AU is played over about twenty seconds, and the orbit takes about 16 hours.

What stays behind is its core, 15 Earths of rock and iron under pressure, about twice the Earth’s width, on the orbit the giant had. Jupiter’s real core is thought to be dilute and spread through its deep interior; a separate dense ball is a simplification. What is left of a giant is not bound tighter or kicked by the pass, as no simulation of that was found.

Giants near their stars

Planets are torn this way near stars as well, and the closest hot Jupiters orbit not far outside their stars’ Roche limits. WASP-12b is stretched by its star’s tide, and its orbit is shrinking. A giant is torn by a star from much closer in than by a hole like this one, as the limit grows with the cube root of the mass doing the tearing.

What’s on screen

The ideas behind what the scene shows, each with what the simulator does and leaves out, and where to read more.

Stars torn apart by black holes

A star that strays too close to a black hole is pulled apart by the difference in its pull.

Gravity weakens with distance, so a black hole pulls harder on the near side of a star than on its far side. Far away that stretch is tiny beside the star’s own gravity, but it grows as the cube of how close the star comes, and inside the tidal radius it wins. That radius is R⋆(M•/M⋆)^⅓: the star’s radius R⋆ times the cube root of how many times heavier the hole, M•, is than the star, M⋆. For the Sun at the four-million-Sun hole in the middle of the Milky Way that is about 0.7 AU.

A star that passes well inside is torn apart; one that only grazes the radius loses its outer layers and goes on, smaller, in a partial disruption. How much it loses depends on how its mass is spread: a star like the Sun, with a dense core, holds on far closer than a red dwarf of uniform density. Of the gas torn off, about half is bound to the hole and half is flung away, because the tide spreads it over a range of orbital energies.

The bound half falls back over weeks to years, at a rate that falls off as t^−5/3, time to the power −5/3, and as it settles round the hole it lights a flare that can outshine the galaxy for months: a tidal disruption event. Around a hundred have been seen, at a rate of about one per galaxy every ten to a hundred thousand years. A hole heavier than about a hundred million Suns has its horizon outside the tidal radius of a star like the Sun, and swallows it whole.

In the simulator. Each pass takes the share of the star that simulations give for its kind and for how close it comes. The gas leaves the star’s near and far tips on Kepler orbits of its own, is turned by Einstein’s law as it passes the hole, and comes back spread smoothly in time, as t^−5/3. The hole takes in only what reaches it, and no faster than its Eddington limit. Until the gas is swallowed or blown away it goes on pulling, so nothing nearby feels the star vanish. The simulator counts all of it as if it sat at the hole, and gas flung away stops pulling on the nearest other body once it has passed it. Where a second hole or a heavy star would bend the gas’s path during its flight, the simulator instead follows that gas in the pull of every heavy body as they move. It does so until the gas falls back on to one hole, whose disk it then lights and feeds, or leaves them all. This gas does not collide with itself or push back except where it shocks at a hole, and it pulls from the place of whichever body pulls hardest on it. Gas round a hole that merges into another goes on round the merged hole. The star is drawn far larger than a real one would be, so its stream is wider and comes back sooner.

Read more

Also in Star torn apart, Star slowly eaten, Star torn by a small black hole.

Roche limits and torn worlds

Close enough to something heavier, a moon, comet or planet is pulled apart by the difference in its pull.

A body held together only by its own gravity is torn apart inside about 2.44 times the radius of what it orbits, scaled by the cube root of their densities: Édouard Roche’s limit, worked out in 1849. A rigid one, held by the strength of its rock as well, survives in to about 1.26 times. Small bodies, held mostly by their strength, can go closer still.

Saturn’s rings lie inside its Roche limit, where their ice cannot gather into a moon. Comet Shoemaker–Levy 9 broke into 21 pieces passing inside Jupiter’s in 1992, and they struck the planet in July 1994. Mars’s moon Phobos is spiralling in, and may be torn into a ring in a few tens of millions of years.

In the simulator. Comets break into strings of fragments inside the limit for a loose pile of ice. Solid worlds hold out to the rigid limit, then crack into pieces and shed dust that shears into a ring. A gas giant, with no strength at all, is torn as a star is, and at a black hole the pieces go on being worn into gas.

Read more

Also in Sungrazer, Rocky planet torn apart, Saturn’s rings.

Places to visit

Zoom out of any scene to reach the galaxy it lives in and the cosmic web beyond it, or go straight there.

Things to try

  • Follow Jupiter in Bodies and zoom in: it stretches before its closest approach and pours gas off both ends after it.
  • Zoom out to follow the stream round the hole as it winds into a disk.
  • Pick Jupiter’s core in Bodies once the gas has gone: 15 Earths, going on round the hole on Jupiter’s orbit.
  • Before it reaches the hole, use Set its orbit in Bodies to give Jupiter a size of 2.8 AU and an eccentricity of 0.29, so it comes no closer than 2 AU: each turn then takes about a third of what is left of it.
  • Compare Rocky world torn apart: an Earth on a similar orbit cracks into pieces instead of pouring away.

More scenarios