OpenWorldLab

Loading interactive view…

Gravity simulator

A sungrazing comet torn apart by tides

A comet falls from far out towards its star on a path that takes it just above the surface. Inside the Roche limit the star’s pull on the near side of the comet beats its pull on the far side by more than the comet’s own gravity can hold, and the comet comes apart.

The Roche limit

Gravity weakens with distance, so a star pulls harder on the side of a comet facing it than on the far side. Far out the difference is tiny, but it grows eightfold each time the distance halves, and inside a certain distance, the Roche limit, it beats the weak gravity holding a loose pile of ice and dust together. For a comet the limit is about two and a half times the star’s radius, and this comet’s closest approach is inside it.

A string of fragments

The comet breaks into six pieces on slightly different orbits. The nearer ones go round a little faster, so the string stretches a little more each time round. Comet Shoemaker–Levy 9 broke up this way passing Jupiter in 1992, and its 21 fragments, strung out like pearls, struck Jupiter one after another in July 1994.

What’s on screen

The ideas behind what the scene shows, each with what the simulator does and leaves out, and where to read more.

Roche limits and torn worlds

Close enough to something heavier, a moon, comet or planet is pulled apart by the difference in its pull.

A body held together only by its own gravity is torn apart inside about 2.44 times the radius of what it orbits, scaled by the cube root of their densities: Édouard Roche’s limit, worked out in 1849. A rigid one, held by the strength of its rock as well, survives in to about 1.26 times. Small bodies, held mostly by their strength, can go closer still.

Saturn’s rings lie inside its Roche limit, where their ice cannot gather into a moon. Comet Shoemaker–Levy 9 broke into 21 pieces passing inside Jupiter’s in 1992, and they struck the planet in July 1994. Mars’s moon Phobos is spiralling in, and may be torn into a ring in a few tens of millions of years.

In the simulator. Comets break into strings of fragments inside the limit for a loose pile of ice. Solid worlds hold out to the rigid limit, then crack into pieces and shed dust that shears into a ring. A gas giant, with no strength at all, is torn as a star is, and at a black hole the pieces go on being worn into gas.

Read more

Also in Rocky planet torn apart, Gas giant torn apart, Saturn’s rings.

Comets

Loose balls of ice and dust from the outer Solar System that grow tails near the Sun.

A comet’s nucleus is a few kilometres of ice and dust from the cold outer Solar System. Near the Sun its ices turn to gas and lift dust off it into a glowing head and two tails: a curved dust tail along its path, and a straight tail of gas blown straight away from the Sun by the solar wind. Halley’s Comet comes back every 76 years. Sungrazers, mostly pieces of one great comet that broke up long ago, skim within a few of the Sun’s radii, and many do not survive.

In the simulator. A comet’s tail points away from the nearest star and grows as it comes closer. Inside its star’s Roche limit a comet breaks into a string of fragments.

Read more

Also in Solar System.

Places to visit

Zoom out of any scene to reach the galaxy it lives in and the cosmic web beyond it, or go straight there.

Things to try

  • Turn on Lasting paths and watch the string of fragments lengthen with each orbit.
  • Pick the comet tool and launch your own comet past the star, close and then not so close, to find the Roche limit.
  • Turn on 3D and Curvature in View to see the star’s well the comet dives into.

More scenarios