Gravity simulator
An Earth torn apart by a black hole
An Earth on a long orbit round a black hole of 4.1 million Suns, as heavy as Sagittarius A* at the centre of the Milky Way. Its orbit runs from 3.6 AU in to half an AU, well inside the distance where the hole’s tide beats the Earth’s own gravity. It cracks on the way in, holds together round the hole, and on the way out is drawn into a stream that gathers into a chain of pieces along its orbit.
Where a solid world comes apart
A black hole pulls harder on the near side of a planet than on the far side, and the difference grows as the cube of how close the planet comes. Roche showed in 1849 that a rigid body holds together in to about 1.26 times the radius of what it orbits, scaled by the cube root of their densities. That suits a small moon, held by the strength of its rock. A world the size of the Earth is held mostly by its own weight, which far exceeds its rock’s strength, so it behaves as a loose pile and is torn at about 1.7 times instead (Holsapple and Michel 2006). For an Earth at this hole that is about 0.8 AU out.
The orbit takes about 12.7 hours, with the fall from its farthest point played over about fifteen seconds. Its closest pass is still six times the hole’s horizon, 0.08 AU, out, but close enough that the orbit is followed under Einstein’s law.
Cracks, then a chain
Coming in, the Earth cracks into rough slabs of no set size, first where the tide pulls hardest. Where the cracks run is chosen at random, not from what lies inside the planet. A world broken this close to the hole would have its pieces scattered by the pass, so it is held together until it is past its closest point.
It then becomes up to 24 pieces strung along its path, each on an orbit of a slightly different energy: the end nearer the hole is more tightly bound and falls behind, the far end runs ahead, and the line lengthens, the same law a torn star’s gas follows (Stone, Sari and Loeb 2013). The rock leaves as a smooth stream, and over about 13 hours, 55 times the time the pass takes, its own gravity gathers most of it into the pieces, the stretches between them clearing first, as simulations of rocky planets torn by white dwarfs found (Malamud and Perets 2020). Comet Shoemaker–Levy 9 was strung out into a line of 21 fragments the same way passing Jupiter in 1992.
What is drawn larger than life
In the default view the Earth is drawn thousands of times its real size, and the chain is laid out by that drawn size, so it is far longer and spreads faster than a real one would; only its proportions are true. Every piece stays bound to the hole, as the real tide could not free any of this orbit’s rock. With True sizes on, the chain is laid out by the Earth’s real size, and it comes back round compact after one orbit. The pieces do not collide or merge, and a grazing pass that should leave a world nearly whole is not modelled. Pieces that return to the hole are ground down into gas, so the hole lights up only later, and faintly.
What’s on screen
The ideas behind what the scene shows, each with what the simulator does and leaves out, and where to read more.
Roche limits and torn worlds
Close enough to something heavier, a moon, comet or planet is pulled apart by the difference in its pull.
A body held together only by its own gravity is torn apart inside about 2.44 times the radius of what it orbits, scaled by the cube root of their densities: Édouard Roche’s limit, worked out in 1849. A rigid one, held by the strength of its rock as well, survives in to about 1.26 times. Small bodies, held mostly by their strength, can go closer still.
Saturn’s rings lie inside its Roche limit, where their ice cannot gather into a moon. Comet Shoemaker–Levy 9 broke into 21 pieces passing inside Jupiter’s in 1992, and they struck the planet in July 1994. Mars’s moon Phobos is spiralling in, and may be torn into a ring in a few tens of millions of years.
In the simulator. Comets break into strings of fragments inside the limit for a loose pile of ice. Solid worlds hold out to the rigid limit, then crack into pieces and shed dust that shears into a ring. A gas giant, with no strength at all, is torn as a star is, and at a black hole the pieces go on being worn into gas.
Read more
- Wikipedia, Roche limit, an introduction.
- K. A. Holsapple and P. Michel (2006), Tidal disruptions: A continuum theory for solid bodies, Icarus: how strength changes the limit.
- B. A. Black and T. Mittal (2015), The demise of Phobos and development of a Martian ring system, Nature Geoscience.
- Wikipedia, Comet Shoemaker–Levy 9.
Also in Sungrazer, Gas giant torn apart, Saturn’s rings.
Places to visit
Zoom out of any scene to reach the galaxy it lives in and the cosmic web beyond it, or go straight there.
- The cosmic web Filaments of galaxies hundreds of millions of light-years long, clusters and voids.
- The Milky Way Our galaxy, with the Sun and its neighbours in their real places.
- Andromeda The nearest large galaxy, where it is seen from the Sun, with M32 and M110.
- The Large Magellanic Cloud The Milky Way’s largest satellite, with the Small Cloud and the Magellanic Stream.
- M87 and the Virgo cluster The giant elliptical with its jet, at its real distance and direction in the web.
- The Antennae Two spiral galaxies in collision.
- The Mice A pair of galaxies drawing out long tidal tails.
- The Whirlpool A grand-design spiral with its companion at the end of an arm.
- The Cartwheel A head-on collision leaving an expanding ring of new stars.
- Arp 273 A spiral whose arms a companion’s plunge threw into a rose.
- The Tadpole A spiral with a single tail of stars 100 kpc long.
- Stephan’s Quintet A compact group: one galaxy crashing through three others, a fifth waiting to fall in.
Things to try
- Follow Earth in Bodies and zoom in as it nears the hole: it cracks, but keeps together until it has passed.
- Zoom out once it has broken, and watch the smooth stream open gaps and gather into a line of pieces along the orbit.
- Turn on True sizes in View and load the preset again: laid out by the Earth’s real size, the chain stays short and comes back round compact after one orbit.
- Launch a planet of your own past the hole with the tools, closer and then further out, to find where worlds start to crack.
More scenarios
- A Jupiter torn apart by a black hole A Jupiter dives at a black hole of 4.1 million Suns. With no rock to hold it, it is drawn out and poured into a stream of gas, leaving only its core.
- A sungrazing comet torn apart by tides A comet dives inside its star’s Roche limit and breaks into a string of fragments, as Comet Shoemaker–Levy 9 did at Jupiter in 1992.
- A star torn apart by a black hole A Sun-like star dives at a black hole and the tide tears it into a stream of gas: half is flung away, half returns to light a fading disk.
