Gravity simulator
A star through a black hole’s disk
A Sun-like star on a circle 24 times the hole’s GM/c² out, tilted 50° to the disk of a black hole of 100 million Suns fed at about a tenth of its limit. It meets the disk twice an orbit, every 2.1 days, at a fifth of the speed of light.
Eruptions on a clock
Since 2019 X-ray telescopes have seen the centres of a few galaxies flare every few hours, as regularly as a clock: quasi-periodic eruptions. The leading idea is a star or a smaller body on an orbit tilted to the disk, which punches through it twice an orbit and splashes out hot gas each time (Linial and Metzger 2023). Those nuclei hold holes of a hundred thousand to a million Suns, where the orbits take hours; here the hole is heavier and the orbit slower, but it works the same way.
Each crossing sweeps up the disk’s gas in the star’s path: Σ·πR², the disk’s mass per unit area times the star’s cross-section, and more the more slanted its path. That gas is hit at the star’s speed, and its kinetic energy becomes heat, shown as a flash. The drag it puts on the star is tiny each time, but it adds up, and slowly brings the star’s orbit down into the disk.
Close enough, but not too close
The star is near enough for Einstein’s law to turn its orbit by a large angle every turn, so the places it crosses the disk move round. It is still far enough out that the tide leaves it alone: a hole this heavy has its tidal radius, ℛt, at 3.5 GM/c², and only a pass within about 20 GM/c² would start to take gas.
What’s on screen
The ideas behind what the scene shows, each with what the simulator does and leaves out, and where to read more.
Accretion disks
Gas falling on a black hole cannot drop straight in. It spirals down through a hot, bright disk.
Gas arriving at a black hole almost always carries too much angular momentum to fall straight in. It settles into a disk, where turbulence, driven by magnetic fields, carries angular momentum outwards so that the gas can spiral in, heating as it goes. Disks are the most efficient engines known: gas that reaches the innermost stable orbit has given off 5.7% of its rest mass as light round a hole that does not spin, and about 30% round one spinning as fast as gas can spin it. Burning hydrogen to helium gives 0.7%.
A thin disk is hottest a little outside its inner edge and cools outwards as r^−¾, the distance to the power −¾. Round a hole of a few Suns that means millions of kelvin, and X-rays; round one of millions of Suns, tens to hundreds of thousands, mostly ultraviolet. Inside the innermost stable circular orbit, three times the horizon for a hole that does not spin, no orbit lasts and the gas plunges in.
In the simulator. Each ring of the disk has the temperature a thin disk round a spinning hole has, and the colour Planck’s law gives it, scaled down to fit a camera’s colours. The side coming towards you is brighter and bluer, and the hole’s gravity bends light from the far side of the disk up over its shadow, so the disk seems to arch over the top, as in the Event Horizon Telescope’s images and the black hole of the film Interstellar.
Read more
- Wikipedia, Accretion disk, an introduction.
- D. N. Page and K. S. Thorne (1974), Disk-Accretion onto a Black Hole. Time-Averaged Structure of Accretion Disk, The Astrophysical Journal: the heat a thin disk gives off.
- S. A. Balbus and J. F. Hawley (1991), A powerful local shear instability in weakly magnetized disks, The Astrophysical Journal: the turbulence that lets gas in.
- O. James and others (2015), Gravitational lensing by spinning black holes in astrophysics, and in the movie Interstellar, Classical and Quantum Gravity: how a disk looks round a hole.
Also in Star torn apart, Star slowly eaten, Quasar.
Quasi-periodic eruptions
X-ray flares that repeat every few hours from some galaxies’ black holes, perhaps from a star punching through a disk.
In 2019 X-ray astronomers found a galaxy whose central black hole flared every nine hours, each flare a hundred times brighter than between them. A handful more have been found since, one of them years after a star was torn apart by its hole. One explanation is a star, or a smaller black hole, on an orbit tilted to the hole’s disk, which it punches through twice an orbit, shocking gas into a flare each time.
In the simulator. The star crosses the disk twice an orbit, sweeping up the gas in its path, which drags on it a little and is shocked into a flare.
Read more
- G. Miniutti and others (2019), Nine-hour X-ray quasi-periodic eruptions from a low-mass black hole galactic nucleus, Nature: the discovery.
- I. Linial and B. D. Metzger (2023), EMRI + TDE = QPE: Periodic X-Ray Flares from Star–Disk Collisions in Galactic Nuclei Revisited, The Astrophysical Journal: a star crossing a disk.
- M. Nicholl and others (2024), Quasi-periodic X-ray eruptions years after a nearby tidal disruption event, Nature: eruptions after a torn star.
Places to visit
Zoom out of any scene to reach the galaxy it lives in and the cosmic web beyond it, or go straight there.
- The cosmic web Filaments of galaxies hundreds of millions of light-years long, clusters and voids.
- The Milky Way Our galaxy, with the Sun and its neighbours in their real places.
- Andromeda The nearest large galaxy, where it is seen from the Sun, with M32 and M110.
- The Large Magellanic Cloud The Milky Way’s largest satellite, with the Small Cloud and the Magellanic Stream.
- M87 and the Virgo cluster The giant elliptical with its jet, at its real distance and direction in the web.
- The Antennae Two spiral galaxies in collision.
- The Mice A pair of galaxies drawing out long tidal tails.
- The Whirlpool A grand-design spiral with its companion at the end of an arm.
- The Cartwheel A head-on collision leaving an expanding ring of new stars.
- Arp 273 A spiral whose arms a companion’s plunge threw into a rose.
- The Tadpole A spiral with a single tail of stars 100 kpc long.
- Stephan’s Quintet A compact group: one galaxy crashing through three others, a fifth waiting to fall in.
Things to try
- Tilt the view edge-on to the disk to see the star go through it, and the flash where it does.
- Move the star in to about 15 AU in Bodies, 15 of the hole’s GM/c²: it starts to lose gas to the tide at each pass, and feeds the disk as Star slowly eaten does.
- Raise the hole’s gas supply: a denser disk takes more from the star at each crossing.
More scenarios
- A quasar A spinning black hole of a billion Suns swallows 20 Suns of gas a year. Its disk outshines a galaxy, and jets leave along its spin.
- A star slowly eaten by a black hole A star bound to a black hole loses gas at every close pass. The gas gathers into a disk while the star shrinks, until the tide can finish it.
- A star torn by a small black hole A Sun-like star passes a black hole of 20 Suns and is mostly torn away. The hole is fed far past its limit, and its disk is slim and white-hot.
