Gravity simulator
A quasar
A black hole of a thousand million Suns with a steady supply of gas. Nothing here is declared a quasar: its mass and how fast the gas arrives give its light, and the light decides what it is called.
What makes one
Gas falling to the last stable orbit gives up 5.7% of its rest mass as light, far more than fusion does. At 20 Suns a year that is the light of about 17 trillion Suns, several hundred galaxies like ours. A hole counts as a quasar here from 10⁴⁵ erg/s, about 260 thousand million Suns, the usual line. Its light cannot pass the Eddington limit, the brightness at which light pushes the gas out as hard as the hole pulls it in; at this mass that takes 39 Suns of gas a year. So a hole of under about 8 million Suns can never be a quasar, however much it is fed: more only blows off as a wind.
Below 1% of the limit, the gas is too thin to radiate before it falls in, and takes most of its heat with it. Sagittarius A* is like this, at well under a millionth of its limit.
Jets
Jets take their power from the hole’s spin, through the magnetic field the gas brings in, so a hole with no spin has none, and they do not need a bright disk: M87’s are fed by a dim one. Coming nearly towards you, a jet’s light is beamed along its motion, so the near one is far brighter than the far one, and looking straight down it you would see a blazar. About nine quasars in ten have no strong jets, for reasons not modelled here.
What’s on screen
The ideas behind what the scene shows, each with what the simulator does and leaves out, and where to read more.
The Eddington limit
How brightly anything can shine before its own light pushes away the gas that feeds it.
Light carries momentum. As it streams out through ionised gas, every electron it scatters is pushed outwards, and the electrons drag the protons with them. At a luminosity of 4πGMm_pc/σ_T, about 33,000 Suns for every Sun’s mass, the push balances gravity: Arthur Eddington’s limit. Here m_p is the proton’s mass and σ_T the electron’s size as a target for light, its Thomson cross-section. A black hole cannot shine much above it while it swallows, and the rate of feeding that would give that light, about a fiftieth of a millionth of its own mass a year, is its Eddington rate: a hundredth of a Sun a year for a hole of half a million Suns.
Feeding faster is possible. Gas can still fall in, carrying its light with it before that light can escape, and what cannot get in is blown off as a wind. The light then grows only slowly with the feeding, about as L_Edd(1 + ln ṁ), where L_Edd is the limit and ṁ is how many times its Eddington rate the hole is fed. Holes newly feeding on a torn star, and perhaps some ultraluminous X-ray sources in nearby galaxies, are fed many times their limit.
In the simulator. A hole fed ṁ times its rate swallows no more than its limit, less what leaves as light, so it gains mass only slowly, and the rest becomes its wind. Inside a star it is different: the gas is so dense that its light is trapped and carried in, so a hole that sinks to a star’s core keeps a quarter of the star, a choice within what simulations allow, and what it takes throws the rest out as an explosion of about 10⁵¹ erg for 2.5 Suns taken, drawn as a hydrogen-rich supernova. The hole of 20 Suns in Star torn by a small hole is fed about a hundred million times its limit at the peak.
Read more
- Wikipedia, Eddington luminosity, an introduction.
- N. I. Shakura and R. A. Sunyaev (1973), Black holes in binary systems. Observational appearance, Astronomy and Astrophysics: disks, and what happens past the limit.
- M. A. Abramowicz and others (1988), Slim accretion disks, The Astrophysical Journal: gas that carries its light in.
Also in Star torn by a small black hole, Star slowly eaten, Star torn apart.
Accretion disks
Gas falling on a black hole cannot drop straight in. It spirals down through a hot, bright disk.
Gas arriving at a black hole almost always carries too much angular momentum to fall straight in. It settles into a disk, where turbulence, driven by magnetic fields, carries angular momentum outwards so that the gas can spiral in, heating as it goes. Disks are the most efficient engines known: gas that reaches the innermost stable orbit has given off 5.7% of its rest mass as light round a hole that does not spin, and about 30% round one spinning as fast as gas can spin it. Burning hydrogen to helium gives 0.7%.
A thin disk is hottest a little outside its inner edge and cools outwards as r^−¾, the distance to the power −¾. Round a hole of a few Suns that means millions of kelvin, and X-rays; round one of millions of Suns, tens to hundreds of thousands, mostly ultraviolet. Inside the innermost stable circular orbit, three times the horizon for a hole that does not spin, no orbit lasts and the gas plunges in.
In the simulator. Each ring of the disk has the temperature a thin disk round a spinning hole has, and the colour Planck’s law gives it, scaled down to fit a camera’s colours. The side coming towards you is brighter and bluer, and the hole’s gravity bends light from the far side of the disk up over its shadow, so the disk seems to arch over the top, as in the Event Horizon Telescope’s images and the black hole of the film Interstellar.
Read more
- Wikipedia, Accretion disk, an introduction.
- D. N. Page and K. S. Thorne (1974), Disk-Accretion onto a Black Hole. Time-Averaged Structure of Accretion Disk, The Astrophysical Journal: the heat a thin disk gives off.
- S. A. Balbus and J. F. Hawley (1991), A powerful local shear instability in weakly magnetized disks, The Astrophysical Journal: the turbulence that lets gas in.
- O. James and others (2015), Gravitational lensing by spinning black holes in astrophysics, and in the movie Interstellar, Classical and Quantum Gravity: how a disk looks round a hole.
Also in Star torn apart, Star slowly eaten, Star through a disk.
Relativistic jets
Some feeding black holes fire narrow beams of plasma at nearly the speed of light along their axes.
A jet draws its power from the hole’s spin. Magnetic field carried in by the gas threads the horizon, the spinning space round the hole winds it up, and the wound field carries rotational energy out along the axis (the Blandford–Znajek process). Simulations find that a hole holding as much field as its gas can bring gives back more energy in its jets than the gas’s whole rest mass.
So a jet needs a spinning hole, a strong field and a flow thick enough to gather it. Most quasars have no strong jets; the one in ten that do can drive them for hundreds of thousands of light years. M87’s jet, the first seen, in 1918, is one. A star torn by a hole has launched one too: Swift J1644+57, seen in 2011.
In the simulator. Jets are not switched on by hand. They appear when the hole spins, gas is arriving, its field is strong, its flow is thick (fed at under 1% of its limit, or over all of it), and no gas stands in their way; the Event horizon section of the hole’s panel says which is missing. A jet seen end on is drawn only a few times brighter than one seen from the side, though a real one would be thousands of times brighter.
Read more
- Wikipedia, Astrophysical jet, an introduction.
- R. D. Blandford and R. L. Znajek (1977), Electromagnetic extraction of energy from Kerr black holes, Monthly Notices of the RAS.
- A. Tchekhovskoy, R. Narayan and J. C. McKinney (2011), Efficient generation of jets from magnetically arrested accretion on a rapidly spinning black hole, Monthly Notices of the RAS Letters: jets stronger than the gas’s rest mass.
- D. N. Burrows and others (2011), Relativistic jet activity from the tidal disruption of a star by a massive black hole, Nature: Swift J1644+57.
Also in SS 433 microquasar.
Radio galaxies and their lobes
Jets from a feeding black hole inflate lobes of radio-bright plasma, often far larger than the galaxy itself.
A jet that leaves its galaxy pushes into the thin hot gas round it. Where it stops, its plasma piles up and flows back round it, inflating a cocoon: a lobe. Electrons spiralling in the lobe’s magnetic field give off synchrotron radiation, mostly at radio wavelengths, so the lobes are invisible to the eye and to optical telescopes but dominate radio maps. They are tens of kiloparsecs to a few megaparsecs long (a megaparsec is about 3.3 million light years); giant radio galaxies pass a megaparsec, and the largest known, Porphyrion, spans about seven.
Fanaroff and Riley sorted them in 1974. In an FR I source the jets are brightest near the galaxy and spread into plumes that fade outward, as in 3C 31. An FR II source, more powerful, has faint narrow jets that end in bright hot spots at the far edges of its lobes, as in Cygnus A. A lobe grows as its jet works against the gas round it: for a steady jet of power Q in gas whose density falls as r^−β, its length grows with its age t as (Q t³)^1/(5−β) (Kaiser and Alexander 1997), so a stronger or older source is larger.
In the simulator. Galaxies whose nuclei launch jets (one active nucleus in ten or so, more in big ellipticals) carry lobes in the web and in the galaxy view, round the galaxy and beyond its stars, along the same axis as the jets drawn in its starlight. A bright nucleus makes an FR II, a weak one an FR I. Their length follows Kaiser and Alexander’s law for a jet carrying a tenth of the nucleus’s accretion power and an age drawn evenly up to 100 million years; that share, the law’s constant, the gas’s density and the FR Is’ half length are choices. They are drawn at their true size. Since no eye sees them, the ordinary view shows them only as a faint hint; Radio lobes in the View settings shows radio light in false colour, dark red to white on a log scale of jet power, over the starlight dimmed to a guide. Lobes bend in the gas of clusters (see Bent radio tails), and their brightness stands for jet power; it is not a measured brightness. Each lobe is drawn at its drawn age and does not grow or fade as the clock runs.
Read more
- Wikipedia, Radio galaxy, an introduction.
- B. L. Fanaroff and J. M. Riley (1974), The morphology of extragalactic radio sources of high and low luminosity, Monthly Notices of the RAS: the two classes.
- C. R. Kaiser and P. Alexander (1997), A self-similar model for extragalactic radio sources, Monthly Notices of the RAS: how a lobe grows.
- B. Mingo and others (2019), Revisiting the Fanaroff–Riley dichotomy and radio-galaxy morphology with the LOFAR Two-Metre Sky Survey (LoTSS), Monthly Notices of the RAS: thousands of FR Is and FR IIs, and their sizes.
- P. Dabhade and others (2020), Giant radio galaxies in the LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey, Astronomy & Astrophysics: sources past a megaparsec.
- M. S. S. L. Oei and others (2024), Black hole jets on the scale of the cosmic web, Nature: Porphyrion, about seven megaparsecs.
- A. L. Kinney and others (2000), Jet directions in Seyfert galaxies, The Astrophysical Journal: jets point any way relative to their discs.
Quasars
A supermassive black hole fed steadily from its galaxy can outshine all of the galaxy’s stars.
Quasars were found in 1963 as faint, star-like points whose light had been stretched by the expansion of the universe, so they had to be very far away and very bright. They are accretion disks round black holes of millions to billions of Suns, fed by gas flowing into the middle of their galaxies, and the brightest give off more than a hundred trillion Suns.
Since a hole cannot shine much above its Eddington limit, a bright quasar needs a heavy hole: shining at 10⁴⁵ erg/s, the usual line for a quasar, takes at least eight million Suns. Fed at less than about 1% of its limit, the gas is too thin to radiate its heat before it falls in, and the hole is faint, as the Milky Way’s is.
In the simulator. Set a black hole’s gas supply in its editor. The disk’s brightness follows the supply as a share of the hole’s limit, and the hole counts as a quasar from 10⁴⁵ erg/s. Where the gas comes from is not worked out: it is only a number.
Read more
- Wikipedia, Quasar, an introduction.
- M. Schmidt (1963), 3C 273: A Star-Like Object with Large Red-Shift, Nature: the first quasar’s distance.
- D. Lynden-Bell (1969), Galactic Nuclei as Collapsed Old Quasars, Nature: black holes and their disks as the engine.
- R. Narayan and I. Yi (1995), Advection-dominated Accretion: Underfed Black Holes and Neutron Stars, The Astrophysical Journal: why thinly fed holes are faint.
Also in Quasar with two black holes.
Places to visit
Zoom out of any scene to reach the galaxy it lives in and the cosmic web beyond it, or go straight there.
- The cosmic web Filaments of galaxies hundreds of millions of light-years long, clusters and voids.
- The Milky Way Our galaxy, with the Sun and its neighbours in their real places.
- Andromeda The nearest large galaxy, where it is seen from the Sun, with M32 and M110.
- The Large Magellanic Cloud The Milky Way’s largest satellite, with the Small Cloud and the Magellanic Stream.
- M87 and the Virgo cluster The giant elliptical with its jet, at its real distance and direction in the web.
- The Antennae Two spiral galaxies in collision.
- The Mice A pair of galaxies drawing out long tidal tails.
- The Whirlpool A grand-design spiral with its companion at the end of an arm.
- The Cartwheel A head-on collision leaving an expanding ring of new stars.
- Arp 273 A spiral whose arms a companion’s plunge threw into a rose.
- The Tadpole A spiral with a single tail of stars 100 kpc long.
- Stephan’s Quintet A compact group: one galaxy crashing through three others, a fifth waiting to fall in.
Things to try
- Pick the hole in Bodies and lower its gas supply: below about 0.4 Suns a year its gas is too thin to shine and it stops being a quasar, though its jets go on.
- Set its spin to 0 and the jets fade. The disk’s inner edge also moves outward, as round a hole without spin the last stable orbit lies further out.
- Turn the view to look down the spin axis, and the near jet brightens into a point.
More scenarios
- A star torn apart by a black hole A Sun-like star dives at a black hole and the tide tears it into a stream of gas: half is flung away, half returns to light a fading disk.
- A star slowly eaten by a black hole A star bound to a black hole loses gas at every close pass. The gas gathers into a disk while the star shrinks, until the tide can finish it.
- Orbits near a black hole Planets swing close to a black hole under Einstein’s gravity: their orbits precess into rosettes, and those that dive too deep cross the horizon.
