Gravity simulator
Tilted orbits: planets out of one plane, one going backwards
A star of one Sun, held in place, with six planets of 30 to 180 Earth masses on circles from 0.4 to 1.9 AU. The innermost lies flat; each further one is tipped more, through 20°, 43°, 69° and 90°, and the outermost is tipped 149°, past upright, so it goes round the other way. The scene opens in 3D.
Tilt and node
Two angles set how an orbit sits. Its inclination, or tilt, is the angle between its plane and a reference plane, here the innermost planet’s. Its node is where it crosses that plane going upwards. Each planet here has a different node as well as a different tilt, so their orbits cross the flat plane along different lines. Past 90° an orbit runs the other way round: one tilted 149° is a backward orbit tipped 31° from flat.
Tilted and backward orbits in the sky
The Sun’s planets formed in one flat disk, so their orbits lie within a few degrees of one another, but not everything does. Pluto’s is tilted 17° and Halley’s Comet’s 162°, and Neptune’s moon Triton goes round backwards. Some planets of other stars orbit over their star’s poles or the wrong way round.
The planets here pull on one another as well as on the star, so each tilted orbit feels a twist from the others, which slowly turns it about their common axis. The star is held in place, so it does not wobble in answer.
A test bed for other laws
Tilted orbits starts its planets on circles for whatever law of gravity is chosen. Under Custom in Physics you can change how the pull falls off with distance and restart. With a pull that falls as 1/r, every planet moves at the same speed: a flat rotation curve, like a galaxy’s. With a pull that grows with distance, like a spring’s, every orbit is a closed ellipse centred on the star. Only that law and Newton’s close every orbit, as Joseph Bertrand proved in 1873; under any other, orbits trace rosettes.
What’s on screen
The ideas behind what the scene shows, each with what the simulator does and leaves out, and where to read more.
Tilted and backward orbits
Not every orbit lies in one plane, or goes the same way round.
The planets formed in one flat disk, so their orbits lie within a few degrees of each other, but not everything does. Pluto’s is tilted by 17°, Neptune’s moon Triton goes round backwards, and some planets of other stars orbit over their star’s poles or the wrong way round. A disk of gas and dust has been found round a binary star at right angles to the pair’s own orbit, a place where planets may form on polar orbits round both stars. A tilted orbit feels a twist from the plane of the others, which turns it slowly about their axis.
In the simulator. Every body has a height, and gravity pulls in all three directions; turn the view to see the orbits’ planes. A scene that starts flat stays flat, as nothing pulls anything out of its plane.
Read more
- G. M. Kennedy and others (2019), A circumbinary protoplanetary disk in a polar configuration, Nature Astronomy.
Also in Polar ring, Kozai–Lidov cycles.
Places to visit
Zoom out of any scene to reach the galaxy it lives in and the cosmic web beyond it, or go straight there.
- The cosmic web Filaments of galaxies hundreds of millions of light-years long, clusters and voids.
- The Milky Way Our galaxy, with the Sun and its neighbours in their real places.
- Andromeda The nearest large galaxy, where it is seen from the Sun, with M32 and M110.
- The Large Magellanic Cloud The Milky Way’s largest satellite, with the Small Cloud and the Magellanic Stream.
- M87 and the Virgo cluster The giant elliptical with its jet, at its real distance and direction in the web.
- The Antennae Two spiral galaxies in collision.
- The Mice A pair of galaxies drawing out long tidal tails.
- The Whirlpool A grand-design spiral with its companion at the end of an arm.
- The Cartwheel A head-on collision leaving an expanding ring of new stars.
- Arp 273 A spiral whose arms a companion’s plunge threw into a rose.
- The Tadpole A spiral with a single tail of stars 100 kpc long.
- Stephan’s Quintet A compact group: one galaxy crashing through three others, a fifth waiting to fall in.
Things to try
- Press Edge-on and then Spin to see each orbit’s tilt, and the backward one crossing the others.
- Click the outermost planet: in Bodies its Tilt reads about 31°, and it goes round the opposite way to the rest.
- Under Physics choose Custom, set the Distance exponent to 1 and Restart: every planet now moves at the same speed.
- Set the exponent to −1 and launch planets in any direction at any speed: each comes back close to where you let it go, and all take about the same time.
More scenarios
- Kozai–Lidov cycles: a planet’s orbit trades its tilt for its stretch A companion star tilted 65° to a planet’s orbit stretches it from a circle to an eccentricity of 0.84 and back, about every thousand years.
- A polar ring round a binary star Rings of planets circle a binary star at right angles to the stars’ own orbit. Such a polar disk is stable, as round the binary HD 98800 B.
- The Solar System on 9 February 1986 The Sun, the planets and their 22 major moons, Pluto and Halley’s Comet where they stood in 1986, or on any date from 1800 to 2050. Real masses, real orbits.
