OpenWorldLab

Loading interactive view…

Gravity simulator

Kozai–Lidov cycles: a planet’s orbit trades its tilt for its stretch

A Jupiter circles a Sun-like star 2 AU out, and a second Sun-like star circles the pair 15 AU out, on an orbit tilted 65° to the planet’s. For centuries little seems to happen. Then the planet’s round orbit stretches until its closest pass is near 0.3 AU, while it lies over towards the companion’s plane, and then rounds out and stands back up. At the opening speed about 20 years go by each second.

A slow twist

Over many laps the companion’s pull on the planet averages into a steady twist on its orbit. The twist leaves the orbit’s size alone. It also leaves alone the part of the orbit’s angular momentum, its amount of turning, along the companion’s axis, which goes as the cosine of the tilt times √(1 − e²), where e is the eccentricity. So the orbit can only trade: as it lies over towards the companion’s plane it must stretch, and as it stands back up it rounds out. Yoshihide Kozai worked this out for asteroids pulled by Jupiter, and Mikhail Lidov for artificial satellites, both in 1962.

How far it goes

It happens only when the tilt is between about 39° and 141°. From a start at 65°, √(1 − 5/3 cos² 65°) gives a greatest eccentricity of 0.84, so the planet’s closest pass falls from 2 AU to about 0.3 AU, a sixth of where it started. At its most stretched its tilt is down near 40°, and the cycle repeats about every thousand years.

The scene runs under Newton’s law, with every body pulling on every other, so nothing is averaged: the stretching comes out of the motion itself, with small wobbles each lap on top of the slow cycle.

Hot Jupiters

Many giant planets circle their stars in a few days, far closer than they could have formed. One way to bring them there is this: a companion stretches a giant’s orbit until its closest passes come so near that the star raises tides in it, which drain the orbit’s energy and leave it small and round. Such planets would often keep a tilt to their star’s spin, and many hot Jupiters do. The planet here never comes closer than about 0.3 AU, so it swings back out each time.

What’s on screen

The ideas behind what the scene shows, each with what the simulator does and leaves out, and where to read more.

Stellar mergers

Two stars in contact lose gas in a spiral, sink together and become one, throwing off gas that glows red.

Two stars so close that both overflow the region each one’s gravity holds share their outer gas. It leaves through the far side of the lighter star and winds out round the pair in a spiral, carrying off more of the orbit’s spin than the stars had to give, so the orbit shrinks, the stars overflow further and lose gas faster: slowly for years and then within a few turns. V1309 Scorpii was a pair circling every 1.4 days whose period shortened faster and faster, and which brightened as its gas left, until in 2008 the two became one. Stars in a crowded cluster can also run into each other, and merge or, fast enough, pass through each other.

When the cores meet, a few hundredths of the pair’s mass is thrown off, mostly near the plane they circled in. As it spreads and cools its hydrogen recombines, and it shines for weeks at tens of thousands of times the Sun’s light, redder as it goes: a luminous red nova. The star left behind is heavier and freshly mixed, which is one way a cluster gets its blue stragglers.

In the simulator. Two ordinary stars that both overflow their Roche lobes lose gas through the outer Lagrange point at a rate fitted to simulations (MacLeod and Loeb 2020), each kilogram taking the angular momentum gas there has, which is what shrinks the orbit; with V1309 Scorpii’s masses this runs away about a year before its outburst, having lost a fortieth of a Sun. The gas is followed as glowing parcels pulled by both stars, so it escapes in a spiral or falls back as the mass ratio decides; how many parcels are drawn, how they spread and how bright they are are choices, and their glow fades more slowly than spreading gas would. Once the surfaces meet, the lighter star plunges in within about an orbit, a rate taken from one simulation, and the two merge when their centres are within three tenths of their summed radii. What the pair loses in all is a fit to simulations of stars falling together (Lombardi and others, 6.4% of two equal stars), the spiral’s share included, and for stars that met fast, a fit made for this simulator to Freitag and Benz’s simulations, which also decide whether they merge or pass through each other. The merged star is left five times its settled size and cooler, a choice within what simulations find, and shrinks back only over its thermal time, millions of years. The gas’s colours are a photograph’s.

Read more

Also in Two stars merging.

Tilted and backward orbits

Not every orbit lies in one plane, or goes the same way round.

The planets formed in one flat disk, so their orbits lie within a few degrees of each other, but not everything does. Pluto’s is tilted by 17°, Neptune’s moon Triton goes round backwards, and some planets of other stars orbit over their star’s poles or the wrong way round. A disk of gas and dust has been found round a binary star at right angles to the pair’s own orbit, a place where planets may form on polar orbits round both stars. A tilted orbit feels a twist from the plane of the others, which turns it slowly about their axis.

In the simulator. Every body has a height, and gravity pulls in all three directions; turn the view to see the orbits’ planes. A scene that starts flat stays flat, as nothing pulls anything out of its plane.

Read more

Also in Tilted orbits, Polar ring.

Places to visit

Zoom out of any scene to reach the galaxy it lives in and the cosmic web beyond it, or go straight there.

Things to try

  • Pick the Planet in Bodies and watch its Eccentricity climb as its Tilt falls from 65° towards 40°, then both swing back.
  • Follow the Planet and turn on Lasting paths: over a few centuries its round orbit stretches until its closest pass is a sixth of where it started.
  • Turn on 3D and press Edge-on: the companion’s orbit is a flat line, and the planet’s orbit leans over towards it as it stretches.

More scenarios