Gravity simulator
A polar ring round a binary star
Two stars circle each other in one plane while three rings of planets go round them at right angles, over the poles of the stars’ orbit. It looks as if it should tip over, yet it holds.
Why a polar ring is stable
A ring tilted to a binary’s orbit feels a twisting pull from the two stars, which makes it precess: the line where it crosses the stars’ plane turns slowly round, while its tilt stays the same. The rate falls with the cosine of the tilt, so at right angles, as here, it stops, and the ring holds its place over the poles. Round stars on an eccentric orbit, rings tilted steeply enough are even drawn towards this polar state.
A real one
In 2019 the ALMA telescope found a disk of gas and dust circling the binary star HD 98800 B at right angles to the stars’ orbit, 150 light-years away. Planets may yet form in it, on orbits like these.
What’s on screen
The ideas behind what the scene shows, each with what the simulator does and leaves out, and where to read more.
Binary stars
Two stars bound together, each circling their shared centre of mass.
Nearly half of stars like the Sun have a companion, and most massive stars do. Each star of a pair circles their centre of mass, the lighter one further out, both in the same time, which Kepler’s third law sets by their total mass: that is how stars are weighed. Planets can circle one star of a pair, or both, like Kepler-16b, though only well outside the pair, beyond two to four times their separation, where the pair’s pull is steady enough. Close pairs swap mass when one swells past the point where its companion’s pull wins.
That point is the inner Lagrange point, between the two. Algol, the Demon Star, shows what follows: its cool subgiant fills its lobe and spills a stream of gas through that point on to its hotter companion. Yet it is the lighter star and the more evolved, which puzzled astronomers until they saw it had been the heavier, aged first, and given most of its mass away.
In the simulator. Launched beside a binary but further from both stars than half their separation, a planet circles the pair’s centre of mass. Follow the pair, in View, keeps that centre in the middle. A star with a life that swells past its Roche lobe spills on to its companion at a rate set by its thermal time, and the stream is drawn as glowing parcels leaving the inner Lagrange point at rest as seen turning with the pair, so they fall in as the real stream does; how many, how large and how bright are choices.
Read more
- Wikipedia, Binary star, an introduction.
- D. Raghavan and others (2010), A Survey of Stellar Families: Multiplicity of Solar-type Stars, The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series.
- M. J. Holman and P. A. Wiegert (1999), Long-Term Stability of Planets in Binary Systems, The Astronomical Journal.
- F. Baron and others (2012), Imaging the Algol Triple System in the H Band with the CHARA Interferometer, The Astrophysical Journal: the masses and sizes Algol uses.
- L. R. Doyle and others (2011), Kepler-16: A Transiting Circumbinary Planet, Science.
Also in Binary star, Kepler-16, Alpha Centauri, Algol.
Tilted and backward orbits
Not every orbit lies in one plane, or goes the same way round.
The planets formed in one flat disk, so their orbits lie within a few degrees of each other, but not everything does. Pluto’s is tilted by 17°, Neptune’s moon Triton goes round backwards, and some planets of other stars orbit over their star’s poles or the wrong way round. A disk of gas and dust has been found round a binary star at right angles to the pair’s own orbit, a place where planets may form on polar orbits round both stars. A tilted orbit feels a twist from the plane of the others, which turns it slowly about their axis.
In the simulator. Every body has a height, and gravity pulls in all three directions; turn the view to see the orbits’ planes. A scene that starts flat stays flat, as nothing pulls anything out of its plane.
Read more
- G. M. Kennedy and others (2019), A circumbinary protoplanetary disk in a polar configuration, Nature Astronomy.
Also in Tilted orbits, Kozai–Lidov cycles.
Places to visit
Zoom out of any scene to reach the galaxy it lives in and the cosmic web beyond it, or go straight there.
- The cosmic web Filaments of galaxies hundreds of millions of light-years long, clusters and voids.
- The Milky Way Our galaxy, with the Sun and its neighbours in their real places.
- Andromeda The nearest large galaxy, where it is seen from the Sun, with M32 and M110.
- The Large Magellanic Cloud The Milky Way’s largest satellite, with the Small Cloud and the Magellanic Stream.
- M87 and the Virgo cluster The giant elliptical with its jet, at its real distance and direction in the web.
- The Antennae Two spiral galaxies in collision.
- The Mice A pair of galaxies drawing out long tidal tails.
- The Whirlpool A grand-design spiral with its companion at the end of an arm.
- The Cartwheel A head-on collision leaving an expanding ring of new stars.
- Arp 273 A spiral whose arms a companion’s plunge threw into a rose.
- The Tadpole A spiral with a single tail of stars 100 kpc long.
- Stephan’s Quintet A compact group: one galaxy crashing through three others, a fifth waiting to fall in.
Things to try
- Press Edge-on and then Spin to see the ring stand upright through the stars’ orbit.
- Turn on Lasting paths to see the rings hold their shape.
- Compare with the binary star preset, whose planets orbit in the stars’ plane.
More scenarios
- A binary star with circumbinary planets A hot blue-white star and a cool orange one circle their centre of mass while rings of planets orbit both, like Tatooine’s twin suns.
- A cluster of seven stars Seven stars scattered through a ball swarm round each other until close encounters fling one out or two merge. Watch a small star cluster evolve.
- The Solar System on 9 February 1986 The Sun, the planets and their 22 major moons, Pluto and Halley’s Comet where they stood in 1986, or on any date from 1800 to 2050. Real masses, real orbits.
