OpenWorldLab

Loading interactive view…

Interference

Which way? A polarisation eraser

Interference needs two ways for light to get somewhere, and no way to tell which one it took. Mark the arms of a Mach–Zehnder with crossed polarisers, set at right angles to each other, and the fringes disappear: the polarisation now says which arm the light came through. Look through a polariser at 45°, which cannot tell the two apart, and the fringes come back. This is the classical twin of the quantum eraser; with single photons the counts follow the same rules.

What you are looking at

A diagonally polarised laser feeds a Mach–Zehnder. One arm passes a horizontal polariser, the other a vertical one, so the beams meet at the second splitter with crossed polarisations.

Output A has a third polariser at 45°, the eraser. The mirror on the piezo sets the path difference between the arms.

How the bench is set up

HeNe laser at +45°, two 50:50 cubes, two flat mirrors, polarisers at 0° and 90° in the arms, a polariser at 45° before output A, and a power meter at each output.

The theory

After the markers the two arms carry E1=E02 x^E_1 = \tfrac{E_0}{2}\,\hat x and E2=E02 eiϕ y^E_2 = \tfrac{E_0}{2}\,e^{i\phi}\,\hat y. Crossed fields add without interfering: the power at an output is ∣E1∣2+∣E2∣2|E_1|^2 + |E_2|^2 whatever ϕ\phi is, so the fringe visibility

V=Pmax−PminPmax+PminV = \frac{P_{max} - P_{min}}{P_{max} + P_{min}}

is zero. A polariser at 45° passes (x^+y^)/2(\hat x + \hat y)/\sqrt2 of each, so after it the two arms are polarised alike and add as E022(1+eiϕ)\tfrac{E_0}{2\sqrt2}(1 + e^{i\phi}): full fringes again, with V=1V = 1, at the price of half the light.

What to measure

Fringe visibility: 0 with the path marked, 1 through the eraser

  1. Open the Fine adjustment of the mirror on the piezo and move the piezo through a few hundred nanometres: output A swings between almost nothing and about 0.5 mW. That is V=1V = 1.
  2. Remove the eraser (select it and press Delete) and move the piezo again: output A stays near 0.5 mW. That is V=0V = 0, though the light still takes both arms.

What the model leaves out

  • The light is a classical wave: one laser beam, not single photons. The visibilities are the same as the photon counts of the quantum version.

Things to try

  • Turn the eraser to −45°: the fringes come back shifted by half a fringe, bright where they were dark.
  • Turn the eraser to 0°: it passes only the horizontal arm, and the fringes stay away. It reads the mark instead of erasing it.
  • Turn one marker to 45°: the arms are then only partly distinguishable, and the visibility falls between 0 and 1.

References

  • M. O. Scully and K. Drühl (1982), Quantum eraser: a proposed photon correlation experiment concerning observation and “delayed choice” in quantum mechanics, Physical Review A 25, 2208.
  • R. Hillmer and P. Kwiat (2007), A do-it-yourself quantum eraser, Scientific American 296(5), 90.

More experiments, and how the lab works, are in the laser lab’s overview.