OpenWorldLab

Loading interactive view…

Diffraction

The Arago spot

In 1818 Augustin Fresnel entered a wave theory of light for a prize of the French Academy. Siméon Poisson, one of the judges, worked out that it predicted something absurd: a bright spot at the centre of a round object’s shadow. François Arago looked, and found it. The spot won the argument for waves.

What you are looking at

A wide laser beam falls on an opaque disc 2 mm across, and the screen 900 mm away catches its shadow.

In the middle of the dark shadow is a bright point, four fifths as bright as the beam with no disc at all. Zoom the screen’s card in on the centre: the spot is a fraction of a millimetre across, ringed by faint circles.

How the bench is set up

HeNe laser expanded to a 3 mm waist, an opaque disc of 1 mm radius 80 mm from it, and a 30 mm screen 900 mm beyond the disc.

The theory

Fresnel’s integral adds up the light reaching a point from every part of the open plane around the disc. On the axis every point of the rim is the same distance away, so the waves from just outside it arrive in step, while the rings further out cancel in pairs. For a plane wave the result is exactly the intensity with no disc. For a Gaussian beam of radius ww it is

I(0)=Iopen(0) e−2a2/w2,I(0) = I_{\text{open}}(0)\,e^{-2a^2/w^2},

here e−2/9=0.80e^{-2/9} = 0.80. Near the axis the spot is the pattern of a bright ring of radius aa seen from a distance LL,

I(r)≈I(0) J02 ⁣(2πarλL),I(r) \approx I(0)\,J_0^2\!\left(\frac{2\pi a r}{\lambda L}\right),

whose first dark ring is at r=0.383 λL/ar = 0.383\,\lambda L/a = 0.218 mm.

What to measure

Spot four-fifths as bright as the open beam, first dark ring at 0.383 λL/a

  1. Read the brightness at the centre of the shadow, then delete the disc and read it again: the ratio should be e−2a2/w2e^{-2a^2/w^2} = 0.80.
  2. Zoom in and measure the radius of the spot’s first dark ring: 0.383 λL/a0.383\,\lambda L/a = 0.218 mm.

What the model leaves out

  • The disc is perfectly round with a perfectly sharp edge. A real one must be smooth to well under the width of a Fresnel zone at its rim, λL/2a\lambda L/2a ≈ 0.3 mm here, or the spot breaks up.
  • Nothing holds the disc. A real one is glued to a glass plate or hung on a fine wire, whose own diffraction adds a streak.

Things to try

  • Raise the laser’s waist to 10 mm: the spot comes ever closer to the open beam’s brightness, as for a plane wave.
  • Double the disc’s radius: the spot shrinks to half the size and dims to e−8/9e^{-8/9} = 0.41 of the open beam.
  • Swap the disc for a pinhole of the same radius: now the centre’s brightness depends on how many Fresnel zones the hole holds, a2/λLa^2/\lambda L = 1.8 here.

References

  • E. Hecht (2017), Optics, 5th edition, Pearson.
  • A. Fresnel (1818), Mémoire sur la diffraction de la lumière, the prize memoir, printed by the Académie des sciences in 1826.

More experiments, and how the lab works, are in the laser lab’s overview.