Gravity simulator
A white dwarf that goes off every 19 years
A white dwarf of 1.25 Suns and a red giant on a ten-day orbit. The giant has just swollen past its Roche lobe and spills hydrogen on to the dwarf at a ten-millionth of a Sun a year, too slowly for it to burn as it lands. It piles up for 19 years, ignites and is thrown off as a nova, then begins piling up again. The scene runs at four years a second, so a nova comes about every five seconds.
Too slow to burn
Hydrogen landing on a white dwarf burns as it lands only in a narrow band of rates, here about three ten-millionths of a Sun a year (Wolf and others, 2013). Faster, the dwarf burns what it can and blows the rest off in a wind, as in the Type Ia preset, whose giant spills about two thousand times faster than this one. Slower, as here, it gathers in a layer on the dwarf’s surface. The base of the layer is squeezed and heated until it starts to fuse. The gas there is degenerate, packed so tightly that heating does not make it expand, so it cannot cool, and the burning runs away and throws the layer off.
One every 19 years
Each nova follows Yaron and others’ (2005) grid of nova models, at the grid point this pair sits on. The layer ignites once it holds 1.9 millionths of a Sun, which at this rate takes 19 years. The nova throws off 1.6 millionths of a Sun at up to 414 km/s and peaks at 48,000 times the Sun’s light, so the dwarf keeps about a sixth of what it took. Only the pace is chosen, four years a second; the recurrence is the models’, not shortened. Each nova shows as a flash, a white fireball over the pair and a crimson shell.
Gaining a sixth of each layer, the dwarf would take millions of years to reach the limit of about 1.4 Suns where it would explode as a Type Ia supernova. Whether recurrent novae grow that far is one of the open questions about where Type Ia supernovae come from.
The pair
The giant was born at 1.2 Suns and is just starting up the giant branch, about 11 times the Sun’s radius. It is placed 0.14 AU from the dwarf, where it overfills its lobe by about 1%, just enough for the simulator’s overflow law to give the rate. Real recurrent novae with giant companions have far wider orbits round far larger giants: RS Ophiuchi’s takes over a year, and it has been seen to erupt seven times since 1898, most recently in 2021. Ordinary novae, on lighter dwarfs fed more slowly, recur every ten thousand years or more.
What’s on screen
The ideas behind what the scene shows, each with what the simulator does and leaves out, and where to read more.
White dwarfs
Earth-sized stellar cores that cool after the loss of their outer layers.
Near the end of its life a star like the Sun sheds its outer layers and leaves its dense core bare: a white dwarf. Electrons packed as tightly as quantum mechanics allows hold it up against gravity (electron degeneracy pressure). With its fusion over, it shines by its stored heat and slowly cools.
A white dwarf in a close binary can take gas from a companion or merge with another white dwarf. Either can set off runaway nuclear burning: a Type Ia supernova.
Hydrogen landing on a white dwarf burns, and how depends on how fast it comes. In a narrow band, a few ten-millionths of a Sun a year, it burns as it lands. Faster, the dwarf burns what it can and blows the rest off in a wind. Slower, it piles up until its base ignites and throws it off as a nova, ten thousand to a million times the Sun’s light, every few years to every hundred thousand.
In the simulator. In Lives of the stars, the lighter stars shed their outer layers and leave white dwarfs. The Type Ia preset starts with a white dwarf taking gas from a giant. A white dwarf that tears a star apart gets its gas millions of times faster than it can burn: it keeps only what it burns, and the rest is blown off its disk in a wind whose glowing photosphere soon hides it. Gas a giant spills on a dwarf burns by the same rules: in the Type Ia preset it comes far too fast, and the dwarf grows at the rate it can burn, so the scene opens on the last twelve seconds of that growth. Novae follow published models of when the hydrogen ignites, what it throws off and how often. The Recurring novae preset shows them at four years a second; a torn star’s gas comes too fast and is gone too soon to make one. Novae that fall closer together than a few seconds of watching, as on a skip through a star’s life, all take their gas, but only one is drawn.
Read more
- NASA, Types of stars.
- M. Wolf and others (2013), Hydrogen burning on accreting white dwarfs, The Astrophysical Journal: where it burns steadily.
- O. Yaron and others (2005), An extended grid of nova models, The Astrophysical Journal: what a nova throws off.
Also in Lives of the stars, Type Ia supernova.
Places to visit
Zoom out of any scene to reach the galaxy it lives in and the cosmic web beyond it, or go straight there.
- The cosmic web Filaments of galaxies hundreds of millions of light-years long, clusters and voids.
- The Milky Way Our galaxy, with the Sun and its neighbours in their real places.
- Andromeda The nearest large galaxy, where it is seen from the Sun, with M32 and M110.
- The Large Magellanic Cloud The Milky Way’s largest satellite, with the Small Cloud and the Magellanic Stream.
- M87 and the Virgo cluster The giant elliptical with its jet, at its real distance and direction in the web.
- The Antennae Two spiral galaxies in collision.
- The Mice A pair of galaxies drawing out long tidal tails.
- The Whirlpool A grand-design spiral with its companion at the end of an arm.
- The Cartwheel A head-on collision leaving an expanding ring of new stars.
- Arp 273 A spiral whose arms a companion’s plunge threw into a rose.
- The Tadpole A spiral with a single tail of stars 100 kpc long.
- Stephan’s Quintet A compact group: one galaxy crashing through three others, a fifth waiting to fall in.
Things to try
- Turn on Lasting paths: at four years a second the ten-day orbit blurs into a ring.
- Press Pause just after a flash, then zoom out to see the shell of thrown-off gas round the pair.
- Move the giant further out under Bodies: it no longer fills its lobe, the spill stops, and no more novae come.
- Make the white dwarf lighter in Bodies: a lighter dwarf needs a thicker layer before it ignites, so the novae come further apart, or stop.
More scenarios
- A white dwarf passes its limit A white dwarf takes gas from an overflowing red giant until it passes the Chandrasekhar limit, burns through in seconds and leaves nothing.
- Algol: the Demon Star spills gas on to its companion In Algol, the Demon Star, a cool subgiant overflows its Roche lobe and spills a stream of gas on to its hot companion, on their measured 2.87-day orbit.
- Stars of every mass meet their ends Six stars from 1.5 to 60 times the Sun’s mass die one by one: as a planetary nebula, as supernovae of two kinds, and as a black hole.
