OpenWorldLab

Loading interactive view…

Light from atoms

Selection rules

Not every pair of states can trade a photon. Mix 1s with 2s and the cloud pulses in and out, but its centre never moves, so no light comes out.

What you are looking at

Hydrogen in an equal mixture of 1s and 2s. The cloud breathes, growing and shrinking, but stays centred on the nucleus. The label at the centre says the dipole is zero at every moment.

The physics

A photon is emitted only if the dipole matrix element between the two states is not zero:

⟨n′l′m′∣ r ∣nlm⟩=∫Rn′l′Rnl r3 dr∫Yl′m′∗ r^ Ylm dΩ.\langle n'l'm'|\,\mathbf r\,|nlm\rangle = \int R_{n'l'} R_{nl}\, r^3\, dr \int Y_{l'm'}^{*}\, \hat{\mathbf r}\, Y_{lm}\, d\Omega.

The angular integral vanishes unless l′=l±1l' = l \pm 1 and m′−mm' - m is −1, 0 or +1. r^\hat{\mathbf r} has the symmetry of a p orbital, so it can only join states whose ll differ by one, and the photon carries away one unit of angular momentum.

2s has no state below it with l=1l = 1, so it cannot decay by one photon. It lasts about 0.12 s, by emitting two photons at once, a hundred million times longer than 2p.

What to measure

Find which of 2s, 2p and 3d give 1s a moving dipole.

  1. Watch the dipole label for 1s + 2s, then change 2s to 2p in the State tab and watch the arrow appear.
  2. Try 1s + 3d: the cloud changes shape but the dipole stays zero.
  3. The check integrates all 393 forbidden pairs up to l = 4 over the sphere and finds each below 10⁻¹⁴.

A common misconception

“Forbidden transitions never happen.” They are forbidden only for a single dipole photon. 2s does decay, by two photons; other “forbidden” lines are seen in the aurora and in nebulae, where atoms wait undisturbed long enough.

What the model leaves out

  • Spin, fine structure and the Lamb shift: hydrogen’s levels here depend on n alone. Each line is really a few lines a few GHz apart.
  • The light is treated one photon at a time, with rates from Fermi’s golden rule; the field itself is not drawn.
  • Quadrupole and magnetic-dipole transitions, which give the weak forbidden lines.

Things to try

  • Open the Light tab and let 2s decay: the lab says it has nowhere to go by one photon.
  • Build 1s + 2p₊₁ + 2p₋₁ and see the arrow’s path.

References

  • H. A. Bethe and E. E. Salpeter, Quantum Mechanics of One- and Two-Electron Atoms (Springer, 1957), part IV.
  • C. J. Foot, Atomic Physics (Oxford, 2005), chapters 2 and 7.

More experiments, and how the lab works, are in the overview of atoms and orbitals.