OpenWorldLab

Loading interactive view…

Why the table has its shape

One table, many shapes

The same 118 elements can be laid out many ways. Each layout tells the same story — the filling of subshells — with a different emphasis.

What you are looking at

Janet’s left-step table, with one row for each value of n+ln + l and the blocks f, d, p, s from left to right. Use the Layout tab to morph between the five layouts.

The physics

The standard table puts elements with similar chemistry in columns, at the cost of tucking the f-block underneath.

The long form keeps every period on one row of 32 columns.

The left-step table (Charles Janet, 1928) orders the rows by n+ln + l, the quantity the filling order follows, so every row ends with an s-block pair and helium sits over beryllium.

Spirals (Theodor Benfey, 1964) make the table continuous: one turn per period, lengthening as new blocks join.

Group 3 here holds scandium, yttrium, lutetium and lawrencium, as the IUPAC project on group 3 recommended in 2021.

What to measure

Check that every row of the left-step table has one value of n + l.

  1. Check that every row of the left-step table holds one value of n+ln + l.
  2. Count the columns of each block in the long form: 2, 14, 10, 6.

A common misconception

“There is one true periodic table.” There are hundreds of published layouts; they disagree about placement (hydrogen, helium, group 3), not about the pattern.

What the model leaves out

  • Chemistry: where an element sits says little about every compound it forms.

Things to try

  • Morph from the spiral to the standard table and follow one element on its way.
  • Colour by category in the left-step table: helium joins the alkaline earths.

References

  • C. Janet, La classification hélicoïdale des éléments chimiques (Beauvais, 1928).
  • E. R. Scerri et al., IUPAC project on the constitution of group 3 of the periodic table, Chemistry International 43, 31 (2021).
  • E. Scerri, The Periodic Table: Its Story and Its Significance, 2nd ed. (Oxford, 2019).

More experiments, and how the lab works, are in the overview of atoms and orbitals.