Why the table has its shape
4s before 3d, and after
Potassium puts its last electron in 4s, not 3d. Yet iron loses its two 4s electrons first when it becomes Fe²⁺. Both are true, because orbital energies move as electrons are added.
What you are looking at
Potassium, with the orbital-energy chart in the Atom tab. Step along Z with the arrows to zinc and watch the 4s and 3d lines.
The physics
In potassium and calcium, 3d is empty and barely bound: an electron there would sit outside the argon core, screened from almost all of the nucleus. 4s penetrates the core and lies lower, so it fills first.
Once 3d starts to fill, its electrons are close to the nucleus and screen one another poorly. Each added proton pulls 3d down faster than 4s, and the lab’s computed 3d energy falls below 4s from titanium on (chromium, with its half-filled 3d⁵ 4s¹, is the one exception).
So in iron 3d lies below 4s, and the electrons that leave first when it ionises are the 4s pair: Fe²⁺ is [Ar] 3d⁶, as its spectra show.
What to measure
Find the Z where the computed 3d energy drops below 4s.
- Find the first Z where the computed 3d energy lies below 4s.
- Open iron and remove two electrons: read the ion’s configuration.
A common misconception
“4s is lower than 3d, so it is filled first and should be emptied last.” The order of orbital energies is not fixed: it depends on how many electrons the atom or ion has.
What the model leaves out
- The atom is spherically averaged and spin-unpolarised: an open subshell’s electrons are spread evenly over its orbitals, with no Hund’s-rule spin alignment and no multiplets.
- Exchange and correlation are approximated locally (LDA). Each electron feels a little of its own charge, so outer orbitals are too weakly bound.
- No spin–orbit coupling: the scalar-relativistic option contracts s and p shells but does not split p into p½ and p³⁄₂.
Things to try
- Look at chromium, where 3d⁵ 4s¹ beats 3d⁴ 4s² (The exceptions).
- Compare the 5s and 4d lines across the next row, and 6s, 5d and 4f across the one after.
References
- M. P. Melrose and E. R. Scerri, Why the 4s orbital is occupied before the 3d, Journal of Chemical Education 73, 498 (1996).
- F. L. Pilar, 4s is always above 3d! Or, how to tell the orbitals from the wavefunctions, Journal of Chemical Education 55, 2 (1978).
- A. Kramida, Yu. Ralchenko, J. Reader and the NIST ASD Team, NIST Atomic Spectra Database, version 5.12 (2024): ground levels and ionisation energies.
More experiments, and how the lab works, are in the overview of atoms and orbitals.
