Why the table has its shape
The exceptions
Chromium should be [Ar] 3d⁴ 4s² by the filling rule. It is [Ar] 3d⁵ 4s¹. Twenty measured elements break the rule like this, and the reason is energy, not magic numbers.
What you are looking at
Chromium with its 3d subshell picked out. The table’s card for any element shows its measured configuration; the element pages say when it breaks the rule.
The physics
The ground configuration is the one with the lowest total energy, not the one the rule predicts. Where 3d and 4s lie close, moving an electron between them costs or saves only a little, and other effects decide.
The lab computes both of chromium’s candidates: 3d⁵ 4s¹ comes out 0.18 eV lower than 3d⁴ 4s², as measured, and copper’s 3d¹⁰ 4s¹ is 2.5 eV lower than 3d⁹ 4s². The real atom gains still more from aligning the five 3d spins, which this spin-unpolarised model leaves out.
The twenty are Cr, Cu, Nb, Mo, Ru, Rh, Pd, Ag, La, Ce, Gd, Pt, Au, Ac, Th, Pa, U, Np, Cm and Lr.
What to measure
Compare the total energies of chromium’s two configurations.
- Compare the total energies of chromium’s two configurations (the checks page computes both).
- Find the exceptions in the table: open each element’s card.
A common misconception
“Half-filled and filled subshells are extra stable, so electrons rearrange to reach them.” That describes the pattern, not the cause, and it fails for tungsten (5d⁴ 6s²) and niobium (4d⁴ 5s¹). The total energy decides.
What the model leaves out
- The atom is spherically averaged and spin-unpolarised: an open subshell’s electrons are spread evenly over its orbitals, with no Hund’s-rule spin alignment and no multiplets.
- Exchange and correlation are approximated locally (LDA). Each electron feels a little of its own charge, so outer orbitals are too weakly bound.
- No spin–orbit coupling: the scalar-relativistic option contracts s and p shells but does not split p into p½ and p³⁄₂.
Things to try
- Compare chromium with molybdenum and tungsten below it: the first two break the rule, tungsten does not.
- Look at palladium, [Kr] 4d¹⁰, with no 5s electron at all.
References
- T. L. Meek and L. C. Allen, Configuration irregularities: deviations from the Madelung rule and inversion of orbital energy levels, Chemical Physics Letters 362, 362 (2002).
- A. Kramida, Yu. Ralchenko, J. Reader and the NIST ASD Team, NIST Atomic Spectra Database, version 5.12 (2024): ground levels and ionisation energies.
- E. Scerri, The Periodic Table: Its Story and Its Significance, 2nd ed. (Oxford, 2019).
More experiments, and how the lab works, are in the overview of atoms and orbitals.
