What an orbital is
Closed shells are round
Add up the densities of all five 3d orbitals, one electron in each, and the lobes fill in to a perfect sphere. This is why closed shells are round.
Try it in the lab
- Drag the starting cloud to look for a preferred direction. The preset adds all five 3d densities.
- Remove one 3d term in Controls → State. Rotate again to find the asymmetry that the full set of orbitals filled in.
What you are looking at
The summed density of the five 3d orbitals, drawn in neutral grey because a mixture has no single phase. Turn it: no direction is special.
What to measure
Turn the summed density and look for any direction it prefers.
- Turn the cloud and look for any direction it prefers.
- Remove one orbital in the State tab and look again.
The physics
Unsöld’s theorem: for any ,
independent of direction. So a full subshell, and a closed-shell atom such as neon, has a spherical charge density.
A common misconception
“Neon’s electrons sit in lobes along the axes.” The lobes of single orbitals cancel exactly in the sum; a closed-shell atom has no orientation.
What the model leaves out
- Spin, fine structure and the Lamb shift: the energies here depend on n alone (the fields experiments add them).
- The nucleus is a point, and the electron moves without relativity.
Things to try
- Try the three 2p orbitals.
- Turn the mixture off: the same five amplitudes as a superposition make one lopsided orbital.
References
- A. Unsöld, Beiträge zur Quantenmechanik der Atome, Annalen der Physik 82, 355 (1927).
- D. J. Griffiths and D. F. Schroeter, Introduction to Quantum Mechanics, 3rd ed. (Cambridge, 2018), chapter 4.
More experiments, and how the lab works, are in the overview of atoms and orbitals.
