What an orbital is
Closed shells are round
Add up the densities of all five 3d orbitals, one electron in each, and the lobes fill in to a perfect sphere. This is why closed shells are round.
What you are looking at
The summed density of the five 3d orbitals, drawn in neutral grey because a mixture has no single phase. Turn it: no direction is special.
The physics
Unsöld’s theorem: for any ,
independent of direction. So a full subshell, and a closed-shell atom such as neon, has a spherical charge density.
What to measure
Turn the summed density and look for any direction it prefers.
- Turn the cloud and look for any direction it prefers.
- Remove one orbital in the State tab and look again.
A common misconception
“Neon’s electrons sit in lobes along the axes.” The lobes of single orbitals cancel exactly in the sum; a closed-shell atom has no orientation.
What the model leaves out
- Spin, fine structure and the Lamb shift: the energies here depend on n alone (the fields experiments add them).
- The nucleus is a point, and the electron moves without relativity.
Things to try
- Try the three 2p orbitals.
- Turn the mixture off: the same five amplitudes as a superposition make one lopsided orbital.
References
- A. Unsöld, Beiträge zur Quantenmechanik der Atome, Annalen der Physik 82, 355 (1927).
- D. J. Griffiths and D. F. Schroeter, Introduction to Quantum Mechanics, 3rd ed. (Cambridge, 2018), chapter 4.
More experiments, and how the lab works, are in the overview of atoms and orbitals.
