OpenWorldLab

Loading interactive view…

Induction and circuits

Lenz’s law: the ring pushes back

The current a moving magnet induces always pushes against the motion that made it. Heinrich Lenz stated the rule in 1834; it is energy conservation in disguise, because the heat in the ring has to be paid for by whoever moves the magnet.

Before you look

Predict first: You drag the magnet through the cut ring. What do you feel?

What you are looking at

Two aluminium rings, closed on the left and cut on the right, and a magnet you hold by the pointer on a stiff spring.

Drag the magnet steadily through both rings. A dashed line joins the magnet to your pointer when it lags. Through the closed ring it lags by a centimetre or two and the ring glows with its current; through the cut ring it keeps up.

The physics

A magnet moving at speed vv along the ring’s axis changes the flux through it at dΦ/dt=v dΦ/dxd\Phi/dt = v\,d\Phi/dx. When the ring’s inductance is small, the current is that EMF over its resistance, and the force on the magnet is

F=−vR(dΦdx)2F = -\frac{v}{R}\left(\frac{d\Phi}{dx}\right)^2

It always opposes vv, and grows with speed: it is a drag, like moving through syrup. The power it takes, Fv=E2/RFv = \mathcal E^2/R, is exactly the heat in the ring.

Going deeper

Vector calculus and Maxwell’s equations

The ring’s own inductance L makes its current lag the EMF by a time L/R, here about 0.4 ms. For a slow pass that hardly matters; for fast ones the drag stops growing with speed, and for a superconducting ring (R → 0) the force is no longer a drag at all but a spring that keeps the flux through the ring constant.

What to measure

Drag force v(dΦ/dx)²/R; the hand’s work becomes heat

  1. Drag the magnet through the closed ring at a steady pace: read the force in the ring’s pill.
  2. Do it at twice the speed: the force doubles.
  3. Pass through the cut ring: its pill shows an EMF but no current and no force.

What the model leaves out

  • Coils, rings and magnets are filament loops, each standing for a bundle of turns or a slice of a magnet’s surface current. Very close to a loop the field is a little lumpy; a few loop spacings away it is exact.
  • Each ring carries a uniform current over its cross-section, which is right well below about 2 kHz for these sizes.
  • Your hand is a spring of 5 Hz, chosen to follow briskly and still show the lag.

Things to try

  • Change the closed ring to copper: its resistance is lower, so the drag is about 1.6 times bigger.
  • Make the ring thicker: more metal, less resistance, more drag.

References

  • D. J. Griffiths (2017), Introduction to Electrodynamics, 4th edition, Cambridge University Press.
  • E. M. Purcell and D. J. Morin (2013), Electricity and Magnetism, 3rd edition, Cambridge University Press.
  • R. P. Feynman, R. B. Leighton and M. Sands, The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Volume II.

More experiments, and how the lab works, are in the lab’s overview.