OpenWorldLab

Loading interactive view…

Fields and Gauss’s law

What field lines can and can’t show

Textbooks teach that field lines are closer where the field is stronger. That is only true in some pictures. Here you can see when it holds and when it can’t.

Before you look

Predict first: The +4 nC charge sends 20 lines. How many leave the −2 nC charge?

What you are looking at

A +4 nC and a −2 nC charge in the slice world: a real 3D field seen through the plane of the screen. The lab draws twice as many lines from the larger charge.

Switch the world to “2D, extruded” in View and compare.

The physics

Lines leaving a charge carry its flux. In 3D, a charge’s NN lines spread over a sphere, so their density on the sphere falls as 1/r21/r^2, just like the field.

But a flat picture shows only the lines in one plane, and their spacing grows as rr, not r2r^2. In a slice, line density can’t show field strength; brightness has to.

Going deeper

Vector calculus and Maxwell’s equations

In the extruded world the field of a line charge really does fall as 1/r1/r, and the lines really are contours of a flux function, so spacing equals strength exactly. The same holds for magnetic lines in the round world, where they are contours of ρAφ\rho A_\varphi.

What to measure

Lines from each charge in proportion to its charge

  1. Count the lines from each charge: 20 from the larger, about 10 arriving at the smaller.

What the model leaves out

  • Which lines are drawn depends on where they start; the field itself is the same whichever lines are shown.

Things to try

  • Turn the line density up and down in View.
  • Compare the flowing texture with the lines: the texture shows strength in both worlds.

References

  • A. Wolf, S. J. Van Hook and E. R. Weeks (1996), Electric field line diagrams don’t work, American Journal of Physics 64, 714.
  • E. M. Purcell and D. J. Morin (2013), Electricity and Magnetism, 3rd edition, Cambridge University Press.

More experiments, and how the lab works, are in the lab’s overview.